Mark Carney’s first year as Prime Minister has sparked a heated debate across Canada. On one hand, critics claim he’s accomplished “basically nothing.” On the other, his supporters argue he’s quietly reshaping the economy. So, who’s right? The latest episode of The Sanity Project dives deep—cutting through the political noise, examining real facts, and asking: Are Canadians seeing meaningful change, or is it all still just talk?
The Reality Check: What Canadians Are Saying
The Strongest Criticisms
Abby Inglewood lays out the toughest version of the “Carney hasn’t delivered” narrative:
Economic credibility was promised, but many feel let down.
Housing affordability remains a crisis: home prices and rent are out of reach for many.
Jobs: The unemployment rate is stuck at 6.7%, barely changing year over year.
Cost of living: While inflation is cooling, everyday essentials are still pricey, and wage growth isn’t keeping up.
Bottom line: Many Canadians still don’t feel the impact of Carney’s policies in their wallets or their daily lives.
What Has Actually Changed? The Policy Rundown
Abby Smith counters that “nothing has been done” is flat-out inaccurate. Here’s what Carney’s government has put in motion:
Budget 2025: Historic Investment
$280 billion in capital investment over 5 years.
$450 billion on a cash basis.
Aiming to unlock up to $1 trillion in total investment through partnerships and incentives.
💡 The government isn’t spending a trillion directly—it’s leveraging policy tools to attract private capital, scaling investment far beyond public spending.
Productivity Superdeduction & Business Incentives
Businesses can immediately expense much larger capital investments.
Covers equipment, clean energy systems, tech infrastructure.
Boosts cash flow, lowers barriers for business modernization.
Estimated to generate $9 billion extra in annual economic output.
Buy Canadian Procurement Policies
Up to $70 billion in government investment will prioritize Canadian-made goods and services.
Strengthens domestic supply chains, supports local industries, and creates stable, long-term demand for Canadian manufacturing and construction.
Trade Diversification Strategy
$5 billion Trade Diversification Corridors Fund for ports, rail, and logistics infrastructure.
Expands Canada’s ability to trade beyond the U.S.—reducing risk from overdependence.
The government is focusing on strategic partnerships (Europe, Southeast Asia, Indo-Pacific), not just instant trade deals.
Laying groundwork through agreements, memoranda of understanding, and targeted projects for energy, critical minerals, and advanced manufacturing.
Tax Relief for the Middle Class
Lowest personal income tax rate cut from 15% to 14%.
Almost 22 million Canadians benefit.
Up to $420 savings per person, $840 for couples.
Housing Support: First-Time Buyer Relief
GST eliminated on new homes up to $1 million for first-time buyers, reduced on homes up to $1.5 million.
Potential savings: up to $50,000.
Not a cure-all for supply shortages, but a tangible financial break for those trying to enter the housing market.
$1 billion over 5 years to expand and make permanent a program providing meals to students across Canada.
Eases household expenses, fights food insecurity, and helps families.
Why Aren’t Results Visible Yet? 🤔
Bo Kauffmann and Abby Smith both highlight the major challenge: Long-term policy doesn’t equal short-term relief.
Infrastructure and trade strategies require years to show results.
Productivity gains and business investments slowly ripple out before they change job numbers or prices.
Voters care about immediate impact: “Is my life easier, can I afford housing, do I feel stable?”
So far, most policies are still in early stages; the frustration comes from this gap between action and everyday results.
The Honest Assessment
Has Carney fixed affordability, jobs, and housing in a year? No.
Has he done nothing? Also no.
Legislation is passed, funding is launched, and measurable objectives are in place.
The real question is: Will these policies deliver results fast enough for Canadians to feel the difference?
Final Thoughts: Incomplete, But Not Absent ✅
Carney’s Track Record—The Highlights
Positive:
Major investment plans
Pro-business incentives
Targeted relief for middle class and first-time buyers
Strategic trade diversification
Still Lacking:
Housing and rent are still high
Job numbers haven’t budged much
Cost of living pressures persist
Abby Smith sums it up: “The gap we are seeing is between action and visible impact.” Economic transformation just isn’t instant; it’s a marathon, not a sprint.
Ready for More Clarity? 📰
Politics doesn’t have to be nonsense. If you found this breakdown helpful, subscribe to The Sanity Project for weekly episodes that make sense of headlines, cut through spin, and tally up the real numbers behind policy.
Drop your thoughts or questions in the comments—what’s your take on Carney’s report card? Are policies moving in the right direction, or do you need more proof?
/
Social Support: National School Food Program